Financial Planning·November 6, 2026

Why Retirement Projections Can Show Both High Success Rates and Early Portfolio Depletion

Retirement planning tools often show a high probability of success alongside scenarios where your savings run out early. Learn why these mixed results occur and how to interpret them for a clearer financial future.


Planning for retirement is one of the most important steps in your financial journey. Many self-directed investors use retirement projection tools to estimate how long their savings might last and to gauge the likelihood of meeting their retirement goals. However, it's common to encounter what seems like a contradiction: your retirement projection might show a high probability of success, while also warning that your portfolio could deplete before the end of your expected lifespan. Let’s explore why this happens and how to make sense of these results.

How Retirement Projections Work

Retirement projections, also called Monte Carlo simulations, are tools that help estimate the likelihood your investments will support your retirement spending needs. Instead of simply assuming a single fixed rate of return each year, these simulations run thousands of possible market scenarios. Each scenario represents a unique combination of returns, inflation, and sometimes spending shocks, showing a range of possible futures for your portfolio.

The simulation then calculates two common results:

  • Success rate: The percentage of scenarios where your portfolio lasts throughout your planned retirement period.
  • Failure scenarios: The percentage of scenarios where your savings run out before the end of your retirement horizon.

Why You Might See a High Success Rate and Early Depletion

It can be confusing to see a projection that shows, for example, a 90% success rate, but also illustrates that in some scenarios, your funds could be exhausted years before your planned end date. Here’s why this happens:

  • Projections show probabilities, not certainties: A high success rate means that in most simulated scenarios, your portfolio lasts as long as you need. However, the remaining scenarios,perhaps 10% in this example,show early depletion. These are not predictions, but possible outcomes based on the range of market returns and spending patterns considered.

  • Market volatility creates a wide range of outcomes: Investment returns are unpredictable. Some scenarios in the simulation will assume a string of poor market years, high inflation, or unexpected large expenses. These negative scenarios can cause your savings to run out early, even though most scenarios are more favorable.

  • The success rate doesn’t show the severity of the failures: The projection might count any scenario where you have at least $1 left at the end as a success, while a failure could mean running out of money with many years left. The success rate tells you how often you avoid running out of money, but not how bad the worst-case scenarios are.

Interpreting Mixed Retirement Projection Results

Understanding both the success rate and the early depletion scenarios is key to making informed decisions. Here are some important points to consider:

1. Look Beyond the Success Rate

While a high probability of success is reassuring, it’s also important to review the details of the failure scenarios. Ask yourself:

  • In the simulations where my portfolio runs out, how early does it happen?
  • Are these failures due to extreme market events, or more moderate downturns?

Some tools will show you the range of outcomes, including how many years your money is projected to last in the least favorable scenarios. This can help you understand the potential risks.

2. Understand the Assumptions

Every retirement projection relies on assumptions about investment returns, inflation, spending, and lifespan. If your spending needs are flexible, or if you have other income sources (like Social Security or a pension), the impact of a depleted portfolio might be less severe.

Review the assumptions in your projection and ask yourself if they reflect your actual situation. Conservative assumptions may show more early depletion, while more optimistic ones might show higher success rates.

3. Consider the Range of Outcomes

Retirement projections are not predictions. They are a tool to help you prepare for a range of possibilities. The presence of early depletion in some scenarios is a reminder to plan for uncertainty. You might want to explore:

  • Building a buffer in your spending plan.
  • Reviewing your asset allocation and risk tolerance.
  • Considering flexible withdrawal strategies that adjust based on market performance.

4. Use Projections as a Conversation Starter

If you’re working with a financial professional, use your projection results to start a deeper conversation about your goals and risk preferences. If you’re managing your own plan, use the results to identify areas where you may want to adjust assumptions or explore contingency plans.

Empowering Yourself With Knowledge

Seeing both a high success rate and early depletion in your retirement projections is not cause for alarm. Instead, it’s an opportunity to understand the uncertainties inherent in investing and to prepare for a variety of outcomes. By interpreting these results thoughtfully, you can make more informed decisions and build greater confidence in your retirement plan.

This article is for informational and educational purposes only and does not constitute financial advice.

Put these ideas to work in your own portfolio

Tilelli gives self-directed investors the tools and education to track, understand, and organize their holdings in one place. Create a free account and see your whole portfolio clearly.

Why Retirement Projections Can Show Both High Success Rates and Early Portfolio Depletion | Tilelli Blog